Reported November 16, 2026: The New York City Council passed Introduction 891-A on November 12, a bill that would bar businesses from using algorithms and consumers’ personal data to charge different prices for the same goods or services. The bill had not yet taken effect: according to the council’s legislative record cited in the original report, it was awaiting the mayor’s signature and would take effect one year after becoming law.
The measure, introduced by Council Speaker Julie Menin, targets what the council calls “surveillance pricing”—using information such as shopping behavior, location and purchase history to tailor prices. It would apply across the city’s five boroughs. The Department of Consumer and Worker Protection would investigate complaints, and violations could carry civil penalties of up to $1,000 each. Separate violations involving different consumers or transactions could be fined separately.
The bill would still permit certain promotions, including loyalty rewards, student and veteran discounts, seasonal sales, coupons and buy-one-get-one offers. It would also require businesses to provide a way for consumers to ask what personal data was considered in setting a particular price and how that data affected it. Eligible small businesses facing a first violation could avoid further penalties by submitting proof of correction within 30 days of notice and returning money obtained through the violation to affected consumers.
In its November 12 announcement, the council cited investigations into pricing practices, including one that found differences of up to 23% in prices shown to customers for some groceries on a major delivery platform. Those examples were offered by the council as context for the bill, not as findings of violations under a law that had yet to take effect.
Source: ithome.com (originally published 2026-11-16 07:23 UTC+8)
